Testing-Driven Reliability Audit of Trajectory-Based Early Outcome Prediction for LLM Agents: Target-Specific Calibration Transfer Persists Within a Single Benchmark

📅 2026-09-21
📈 Citations: 0
✨ Influential: 0
📄 PDF
🤖 AI Summary
研究通过多种校准审计方法,解决了早期结果预测器在不同代理上的校准转移问题,发现特定目标组合存在持续的校准转移错误。
📝 Abstract
Predicting early outcomes based on trajectory can decrease the expenses associated with agent evaluation by terminating a run once the outcome becomes sufficiently predictable, assuming that the predictor's confidence is properly calibrated. Calibration is at risk when a predictor is applied to an agent on which it was never trained, but it is not known whether such transfer failures are broad across agent systems or concentrated in specific target agent/head combinations. Using public SWE-bench Verified trajectories and a frozen dual-head early-outcome prediction pipeline, we ran a leave-one-agent-out calibration audit, a shared-predictor leave-two-agents-out control, oracle prior correction, and a robustness battery over training cohorts, task resampling, task halves, jackknife, and thresholds. Fixed-scaffold TerminalBench analysis served as a pre-registered boundary test. Broad same-predictor pairwise heterogeneity was not supported; the median pairwise corrected-gap differences were 0.0180 (SUCCESS head, 45 pairs) and 0.0385 (FAILURE head, 35 pairs), and the pre-registered heterogeneity criterion was not met on either head. Two specific combinations, gpt-5-mini/SUCCESS and claude-opus-4.6/FAILURE, showed persistent calibration-transfer errors (median corrected gaps 0.1377 and 0.1107) without a sign reversal under any frozen control. TerminalBench did not establish cross-benchmark replication: the success target produced zero decisions (INDETERMINATE), and the failure target did not satisfy the pre-registered persistence criterion. Therefore, a strong target-specific calibration-transfer error can exist within one frozen environment, but the evidence does not establish that the error is intrinsic to the model or general across benchmarks.
Problem

Research questions and friction points this paper is trying to address.

trajectory-based early outcome prediction
calibration transfer
LLM agents
Innovation

Methods, ideas, or system contributions that make the work stand out.

calibration transfer
early outcome prediction
reliability audit
target-specific error
trajectory-based
💼 Related Jobs
No related jobs found.
Y
YanZe Cao
Lizhi College, Shaanxi University of Technology, No. 1 East 1st Ring Road, Hantai District, Hanzhong, Shaanxi 723001, China