🤖 AI Summary
This study addresses the challenges UX designers face in data visualization due to limited domain knowledge and tool expertise. It presents the first systematic comparison of three guidance approaches—static presentation, scrollytelling, and chatbot-based interaction—in authentic design tasks, proposing three core design dimensions for effective visualization guidance: narrative structure, visual content layout, and navigation flexibility. Through a controlled experiment, surveys, and in-depth interviews with 25 UX designers and students, the research evaluates both performance and user experience. Findings indicate that interactive guidance (either scrollytelling or chatbot) significantly enhances adherence to design conventions and user engagement, while also providing clearer instructions compared to static guidance. However, no significant differences emerged between the two interactive modalities, and all groups demonstrated comparable levels of visualization comprehension.
📝 Abstract
User experience (UX) designers face barriers when creating data visualizations due to limited domain expertise in visualization or unfamiliarity with specialized tools. This highlights a clear need for effective methods to build visualization literacy. To address this, we evaluated three visualization onboarding techniques -- static, scrollytelling, and chatbot -- in an experimental study with 25 UX designers and students. We measured visualization comprehension and guideline adherence during a visualization creation task, followed by surveys and interviews to capture preferences and experiences. Compared to static onboarding, the pooled interactive condition (scrollytelling or chatbot) was associated with significantly higher guideline-adherence scores during visualization creation; both interactive techniques also received higher engagement ratings. Instruction clarity ratings were significantly higher when the two interactive conditions were pooled. Comprehension did not differ significantly across conditions. While participants generally preferred the interactive techniques, no significant differences emerged between scrollytelling and chatbot in performance or onboarding experience ratings. Drawing on the findings, we discuss three design dimensions of visualization onboarding (narrative structure, visual content layout, and navigational flexibility), their design implications, and potential opportunities for future research in this field.