Identification- and many instrument-robust inference via invariant moment conditions

📅 2023-03-14
📈 Citations: 5
Influential: 0
📄 PDF
🤖 AI Summary
This paper addresses the failure of conventional generalized method of moments (GMM) tests under high-dimensional moment conditions—where the number of moments grows at the same rate as the sample size. Under such settings, standard weighted GMM tests become asymptotically conservative and fail to control Type I error when the null-implied moment conditions satisfy reflection invariance. We propose a robust inference framework grounded in reflection invariance. First, we establish a novel theoretical link between the structure of the weighting matrix and reflection invariance, demonstrating that conventional weighting induces size distortion. Building on this insight, we construct an asymptotically exact invariant test. Our theory guarantees consistent size control, and simulations confirm accurate finite-sample significance levels after correction. Empirically, applying the method to banking data reveals that greater concentration in financial activities exacerbates systemic risk.
📝 Abstract
Identification-robust hypothesis tests are commonly based on the continuous updating GMM objective function. When the number of moment conditions grows proportionally with the sample size, the large-dimensional weighting matrix prohibits the use of conventional asymptotic approximations and the behavior of these tests remains unknown. We show that the structure of the weighting matrix opens up an alternative route to asymptotic results when, under the null hypothesis, the distribution of the moment conditions is reflection invariant. We provide several examples in which the invariance follows from standard assumptions. Our results show that existing tests will be asymptotically conservative, and we propose an adjustment to attain asymptotically nominal size. We illustrate our findings through simulations for various (non-)linear models, and an empirical application on the effect of the concentration of financial activities in banks on systemic risk.
Problem

Research questions and friction points this paper is trying to address.

Develops robust hypothesis tests with many moment conditions
Addresses asymptotic issues in large-dimensional weighting matrices
Proposes adjustment for nominal test size in invariant models
Innovation

Methods, ideas, or system contributions that make the work stand out.

Uses invariant moment conditions for robust inference
Adjusts tests to achieve nominal size asymptotically
Applies reflection invariance to handle large-dimensional weighting matrices
🔎 Similar Papers
No similar papers found.
Tom Boot
Tom Boot
Associate Professor, University of Groningen
Econometrics
J
Johannes W. Ligtenberg
Erasmus University Rotterdam, Burgemeester Oudlaan 50, 3062 PA Rotterdam, The Netherlands